A trusted auctioneer and auction expert witness -- with unmatched knowledge of both auction law and customary practice.
🌐 Visit Mikebrandlyauctioneer.wordpress.com
🌐 Mikebrandlyauctioneer.wordpress.com besuchen
✍️Write rieview ✍️Rezension schreiben 🏷️Get Badge! 🏷️Abzeichen holen! ⚙️Edit entry ⚙️Eintrag bearbeiten 📰News 📰Neuigkeiten
Running a successful auction requires skill, professionalism, and strategic thinking. While auctioneers often focus on perfecting their bid calling and …
14.3.2025 07:2210 things auctioneers should always do?Running a successful auction requires skill, professionalism, and strategic thinking. While auctioneers often focus on perfecting their bid calling and …
12.3.2025 07:4910 things auctioneers should never do?The auction industry, like many sectors of the economy, is influenced by the policies and priorities of the sitting president. …
10.3.2025 08:08Presidents and the auction industryThe United States has long maintained a system of federal and state programs to support citizens during times of need. …
6.3.2025 09:04Auctioneers: Limited government is good until it’s not<!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>Excellent </p> <!-- /wp:paragraph -->
10.2.2025 04:48Comment on Didn’t meet the published reserve — auctioneer sells for less? by Steve HummelIn the world of real estate (or any property) auctions, transparency and adherence to advertised terms are crucial. A scenario …
9.2.2025 21:23Didn’t meet the published reserve — auctioneer sells for less?Bidders participating in auctions are driven by a universal motivation: the prospect of a deal. Whether they are bidding on a $100 …
8.2.2025 04:48Auctions: What if it’s not a $100 Bill?I keep seeing auctioneers share this statement on social media: “There’s nothing more expensive than the cheapest auctioneer you can …
2.2.2025 13:06There’s nothing more expensive …?Auctions are dynamic marketplaces where the value of items is determined by the interplay of demand and competition. This open …
28.1.2025 09:07Strategic bidding rather than organic competition?In any online or social media discussion, it is common to encounter questions posed by participants. On the surface, these …
26.1.2025 09:09Auctioneer confusion or skepticism?When participating in auctions—whether live or online—you might wonder whether auction companies can be trusted to keep your personal information …
22.1.2025 09:11Is my information safe with an auction company?Auctioneers can facilitate tobacco sales, but the ability to do so depends on several factors, including state and federal regulations, …
18.1.2025 09:04Auctioneers and selling/shipping tobacco productsIn Alex Lyon & Son, Sales Managers & Auctioneers, Inc. v. Leach, 846 S.E.2d 51 (W. Va. 2020), the West …
14.1.2025 09:09“Equal footing” is not “discretionary”Low starting prices, even as low as $1.00, have been shown to produce higher final prices at auction by encouraging …
10.1.2025 09:04The $1.00 start helps the auction seller[…] much shipping may end up costing you. Auctioneer Mike Brandly illustrated this potential pitfall in his blog with the case of a $3 stuffed bear that ended up costing the buyer $42.50 to […]
9.1.2025 21:02Comment on Auction shipping costs by Avoiding Auction Shipping Pitfalls: What Buyers Need to Know - NichiblesIrrevocable bids in auctions are those that cannot be withdrawn once placed, creating a binding obligation for the bidder. This …
9.1.2025 09:11Irrevocable Bids in Auctions: Concepts and Legal ConsiderationsIn the world of auctions, the distinction between auction software platforms and auction companies has become increasingly blurred. Traditionally, auction …
8.1.2025 09:05The Blurred Lines: Auction Software Platforms vs. Auction CompaniesAuctioneering at the elite level goes beyond simply calling bids in a fast-paced environment; it is a refined art that …
7.1.2025 09:21Auctioneering at the Elite LevelUsing AI intelligently as an auctioneer can significantly enhance the efficiency, accuracy, and overall experience of an auction. While the …
6.1.2025 09:04Using AI intelligently as an auctioneerJudging auctioneers by the type and value of property they sell can offer valuable insights into their expertise and skill …
5.1.2025 09:06Judging auctioneers by the type and value of property they sellSome auctioneers may struggle with a fundamental aspect of the profession: they do not set prices. Auctioneers often find themselves …
4.1.2025 09:17Some auctioneers don’t understand?Auctioneers and sellers must understand the implications of express and implied warranties when conducting an auction. These legal concepts affect …
3.1.2025 09:07Auction Express and Implied WarrantiesIn reply to <a href="https://mikebrandlyauctioneer.wordpress.com/2025/01/01/auction-terms-and-conditions-authority-fairness-and-legal-implications/#comment-177065">sterrel</a>. Good questions, Shawn. This is somewhat akin to what Alex Lyon did, where the Court held should not (can't) be done. Yet, your terms could outline strict registration requirements and then say "or" other detailed requirements allowing other bidders to register. "Any individuals unknown" is somewhat equal to "unequal footing" which the court found problematic.
1.1.2025 18:15Comment on Auction Terms and Conditions: Authority, Fairness, and Legal Implications by Mike Brandly<!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>Mike,</p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>this is a little long but important, so bare with me...</p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>A question about the "equal footing" comment with regard to bidders in a real estate auction. Was it not part of the courts findings in the Alex Lyon & Sons case, that their Terms & Conditions did not provide for or spell out the potential for additional registration requirements pertaining to bidders that may be either unknown by the seller or auctioneer, or that may be deemed a higher potential risk to purchase and complete the transaction. I believe we discussed this case in the past where their Terms & Conditions simply stated these are the set standards for registration, with no latitude for altering them on a case by case basis.</p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>The issue i see with standardizing a one-size fits all registration requirement in the T&C, can be explained in the following scenario:</p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph --> <p><strong>Typical Scenario: </strong>The auction sale type is a 160 acre cropland farm expected to bring ($800,000+/-), and the typical registration requirements are: 1. Photo ID, 2. Signing the T&C, and 3. Acceptance of the Offering Packet, which then results in being issues a bidders number. The expected cliental for this type of auction is normally area farmers that will fold this cropland into their existing operations, and maybe a few investors that purchase the cropland and rent it out. THEN, during registration you have a local person that is known in the community for not being very stable financially and is a repeat offender for not honoring their obligations. </p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>Not providing a heightened set of registration qualifications for this known individual is just not practical, and is incurring a lot of risk for a seller who just spent $$ thousands on auction marketing for their event. Some might argue that you just need to set more stringent registration requirements for "everyone". <strong>Problem:</strong> we know from our 30 years in the land auction industry, that by getting too aggressive with registration requirements and asking local farmers and investors to present financial statements, proof of funds, etc.., has "proven" to deter some bidders from engagement. This can clearly diminish bidding activity from less bidders and ultimately sales value for the Seller. </p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph --> <p><strong>Summary: </strong>We have been including registration requirement language that offers latitude for bidders that are unknown to the Seller or the Auction Company, which we would hope will stand up if ever brought into court. something to the effect of "Seller reserves the right to require additional registration requirements for any individuals that are unknown to Seller or the Auction Company". </p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>Thoughts?? </p> <!-- /wp:paragraph -->
1.1.2025 17:20Comment on Auction Terms and Conditions: Authority, Fairness, and Legal Implications by sterrelIn reply to <a href="https://mikebrandlyauctioneer.wordpress.com/2024/12/29/auction-licensing-and-the-limits-on-free-speech/#comment-177062">John Wells</a>. I've not heard any rumblings -- yet. You make a good point, doesn't that infringe on First Amendment protections?
29.12.2024 17:25Comment on Auction licensing and the limits on “free speech” by Mike Brandly<!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>This information causes me to wonder if the new requirement for Realtors, to have a buyer agent agreement before giving any information to a prospective buyer, doesn't violate the 1st amendments freedom of speech. </p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>Have you heard any rumblings along this line?</p> <!-- /wp:paragraph -->
29.12.2024 17:18Comment on Auction licensing and the limits on “free speech” by John WellsIn reply to <a href="https://mikebrandlyauctioneer.wordpress.com/2024/12/29/auction-licensing-and-the-limits-on-free-speech/#comment-177060">Mike Brandly</a>. <!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>Thanks for the quick response Mike, and that makes sense. Yet, another great article and i agree with your comments. Best wishes, </p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph --> <p></p> <!-- /wp:paragraph -->
29.12.2024 13:45Comment on Auction licensing and the limits on “free speech” by sterrelIn reply to <a href="https://mikebrandlyauctioneer.wordpress.com/2024/12/29/auction-licensing-and-the-limits-on-free-speech/#comment-177059">sterrel</a>. I believe after Will won, the State appealed and won lifting the injunction. I think that was August, 2023.
29.12.2024 13:43Comment on Auction licensing and the limits on “free speech” by Mike Brandly<!-- wp:paragraph --> Interesting article Mike and great job putting this together. Can you elaborate on why or how Tennessee still requires licensing for online auctions, if Will won his case in court? I was aware of the lawsuit but not the outcome. <!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph --> Thanks again for all you do. <!-- /wp:paragraph -->
29.12.2024 13:38Comment on Auction licensing and the limits on “free speech” by sterrelIn reply to <a href="https://mikebrandlyauctioneer.wordpress.com/2024/12/27/auctions-throughout-history/#comment-177055">sterrel</a>. Thank you. It was interesting researching. Here’s to a great 2025!
27.12.2024 21:24Comment on Auctions Throughout History by Mike Brandly<!-- wp:paragraph --> <p> Great information and thank you for sharing this Mike. There’s a lot of history and heritage in the Auction business.</p> <!-- /wp:paragraph -->
27.12.2024 15:20Comment on Auctions Throughout History by sterrel<!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>Incredible Year End Message!!</p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>We live in Victoria, Vancouver Island Canada !</p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>The Real Estate Auction potential in this part of the Planet is extraordinary.</p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>Your messages are focused exactly towards our challenges. </p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p>THANK YOU!!</p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p></p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p></p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph -->
<p></p>
<!-- /wp:paragraph -->
<!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>However in nyc since Covid, it is almost unheard of to have a live auction with items. in my 40years as a benefit auctioneer I endorse almost all of these concepts. An auctioneer cannot just stand up on the podium five minutes before without being an intergal part of the planning of the event with the organization. But the trend is in a fund a cause, or sometimes called a reverse auction, where I take bids from high to low from the room for a common cause. Hopefully the goal is something the organization needs but cannot afford; stage lighting for a non profit theatre, a Steinway piano for a school who can only rent one, etc. it’s about creating community spirit and 100 % participation from the room. Everyone goes home singing when the auctioneer is skilled and they can drum up the palpable excitement. I have learned we all have to move with the times and create a new model.</p> <!-- /wp:paragraph -->
24.12.2024 12:07Comment on The Art of Successful Benefit Auctions by Kathleen Guzman[…] One attorney remarked that $3.5 million was more than $1.75 million — exhibiting the principle that people can sense fairness on its face. We noted such here: https://mikebrandlyauctioneer.wordpress.com/2021/06/03/unnecessary-risk-really-bad-advice/. […]
16.12.2024 09:12Comment on Unnecessary risk & really bad advice by InfoWars auction transparancy | Mike Brandly, Auctioneer Blog<!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>Well said Mike, </p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>It makes no sense for a state licensing board to not have a full understanding of rules and regulations they oversee. At the end of the day, if an auctioneer board is unclear when asked about a situation in advance, they should be disarmed for governance after the fact.</p> <!-- /wp:paragraph --><!-- wp:paragraph --> <p>we need more guidance in situations like the ones you mentioned. </p> <!-- /wp:paragraph -->
9.12.2024 15:54Comment on State creates law, but won’t interpret? by sterrel[…] Here we wrote about this same phenomenon in 2016 where a different state would not help the subject auctioneer comply with the law, but would interpret the law to discipline this same auctioneer: https://mikebrandlyauctioneer.wordpress.com/2016/05/11/auctioneer-regulation-authoritarianism/. […]
9.12.2024 09:12Comment on Auctioneer regulation authoritarianism by State creates law, but won’t interpret? | Mike Brandly, Auctioneer BlogIn reply to <a href="https://mikebrandlyauctioneer.wordpress.com/2024/12/05/your-terms-state-law-which-is-it/#comment-177040">ginaboyleston</a>. Prompt is ambiguous, but the standard would be "reasonable time given the circumstances." Also ambiguous I suppose?
6.12.2024 04:18Comment on Your terms? State law? Which is it? by Mike Brandly<!-- wp:paragraph --> What time frame is considered a prompt refund? Once a seller is paid, how long must an auctioneer be responsible for refunds? A week, month, year, decade? The term prompt appears ambiguous and open to debate. <!-- /wp:paragraph -->
5.12.2024 13:09Comment on Your terms? State law? Which is it? by ginaboyleston[…] Lastly, be careful using words like “best efforts,” “reasonable efforts,” or “commercially reasonable efforts” in conversation unless you expect your client to hold you to such. Outside the written contract would be possibly considered parol evidence but could invite a disappointed seller: https://mikebrandlyauctioneer.wordpress.com/2022/11/18/auctions-and-parole-evidence/. […]
25.11.2024 09:18Comment on Auctions and parol evidence by Does your contract have an “efforts” clause? | Mike Brandly, Auctioneer Blog[…] We wrote about “commercially reasonable auctions” which are largely such with or without denoting in the contract: https://mikebrandlyauctioneer.wordpress.com/2014/06/23/commercially-reasonable-auctions/. […]
25.11.2024 09:18Comment on Commercially reasonable auctions by Does your contract have an “efforts” clause? | Mike Brandly, Auctioneer Blog⬆️
⬇️